Written by Kelly Burch
Published Oct 22, 2026 | 7 minute read
A fresh set of tires can dramatically improve your vehicle’s stopping distance, fuel economy and wet-weather grip while increasing your general comfort. But tire costs can be confusing. This guide breaks down what you can expect to pay for new tires and installation, how to know when it’s time to replace your tires and how to choose the right tire without overspending.
For four new tires, typical drivers can expect to spend about $500–$1,200 out the door (meaning tires plus installation and basic fees). Per-tire prices vary by vehicle size and whether the tires are all-season or seasonal. Tires for smaller vehicles will be less expensive than those for a larger vehicle, like a sedan or a bigger truck.
Labor costs for installation fluctuate depending on your location. In 2025, Consumer Reports’ members paid an average of $212 per tire.
For a midsize crossover vehicle with four new mid-grade, all season tires, you can expect to pay up to $160 per tire, or $640 total. Mounting and balancing plus valves and disposal adds roughly $100, and a four-wheel alignment is about $120 — so you can plan on spending about $860 out the door for this vehicle.
If you have a tight budget, you can save by choosing reliable mid-grade tire models, keeping an eye out for manufacturer rebates and asking the shop to quote two or three options so you can compare value, treadwear warranties and road-hazard coverage.
READ MORE: 10 Ways to Make Your Tires Last Longer and Save Money
This is the big question that you will want to consider carefully.
Get new tires if:
Wait to purchase new tires if:
Use a simple penny test to see if your treads are at 2/32”, which is the threshold at which the U.S. Department of Transportation suggests you replace tires.
Place a penny between your tire treads and turn it so the top of Lincoln’s head faces the ground. If you’re still able to see the top of Lincoln’s head, your tires probably need to be replaced. If the top of his head disappears below the tread, your tires likely have some life left in them.
If your tire treads are close to the 2/32” threshold, you should plan to replace them soon. At around 3/32–4/32”, the tire grip on wet roads and resistance to hydroplaning drop off fast.
If your tread is above 5/32”, the wear is even and there’s no visible damage, you can continue to monitor and maintain your tires by having them rotated at least every other oil change and keeping the tire pressure set to the level listed on your driver-door sticker.
In addition to the tread depth penny test, look for the following warning signs:
If you notice any of the above warning signs, have a qualified technician measure all four tires, check alignment and inspect your tires for damage to help you make your all-important tire replacement decision.
For most commuters, all-season or touring tires will meet your needs — they perform well year-round, have good traction and provide a comfortable ride. Performance tires can sharpen your vehicle’s handling and braking but may ride firmer and wear faster.
If you split driving time between pavement and gravel or dirt, all-terrain tires add bite (and a bit more road noise). In snowy regions where temperatures routinely dip below 45°F, winter or snow tires can increase your safety. You can put them on in late fall for winter use, then take them off in the spring.
READ MORE: LT vs. P Tires: How To Choose the Right Tire Size
It’s best to replace all four tires at once for even traction and braking, particularly on all-wheel drive vehicles that can be sensitive to tire circumference differences.
Consumer Reports suggests that in some instances, replacing two tires on the same axel might make sense. You may be able to get away with replacing a single tire if the other three are less than about 30% worn. But most of the time, you should plan to replace all four tires to avoid performance issues.
Many all-season tires are built for about 55,000–85,000 miles (roughly four to six years of typical driving). High-performance or all-terrain tires may wear faster due to softer compounds or more aggressive tread. Regardless of the condition of the treads, you should replace any tire that’s 10 years out from its manufacture date, as the rubber can begin to break down.
To get the most out of your new tires, follow these guidelines:
Synchrony helps you get the most out of everyday life. Explore our financing and savings products, deals and offers from the brands you love. Learn more.
Kelly Burch is a freelance writer with more than a decade of experience writing about automotive and finance topics. Her work has appeared in national and international newspapers and magazines, and she's created messaging for well-known brands including CarMax, Trivago and Synchrony. When she's not behind the desk, Kelly can be found in the mountains and lakes that surround her New Hampshire home.
We include links to other websites in this article for your convenience. We do not endorse any content on these sites. All product names, logos, and brands are property of their respective owners. All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes only. Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement. This content is subject to change without notice and offered for informational use only. You are urged to consult with your individual advisors with respect to any information presented. Synchrony and any of its affiliates (collectively, “Synchrony”) make no representations or warranties regarding this content and accept no liability for any loss or harm arising from the use of the information provided. Your receipt of this material constitutes your acceptance of these terms and conditions.