How Much Does it Cost to Replace Your Furnace?

Snow is falling, wind is howling, and your furnace is… whistling? That sinking feeling you might have is one many homeowners know all too well. Because the last time this happened, you were told it was almost time to say goodbye to your aging furnace – and it seems the time has come.

Before you have to bundle up in every blanket you own, let's figure out how much you might expect to pay to replace your furnace. We'll look at the average costs by size, type, and efficiency – all of which can affect the price tag — and explore additional costs so you have a better idea of how much to expect overall.

On average, a furnace can last 15 to 20 years with proper maintenance. However, if you notice the following signs, it's probably time to start thinking about replacement.

• The furnace is over 15–20 years old.
• Your heating bills are rising despite stable energy rates.
• The furnace needs frequent repairs.
• There are cold spots in your home, indicating uneven heating.
• Strange noises, like banging or rattling, are becoming common.
• Your air feels noticeably more or less humid than normal.
• You're having to constantly adjust your thermostat.
• The furnace is turning on and off frequently.
• There's extra dust or soot on or around the furnace.
• You're calling for repairs more than twice a year, or the repairs would cost more than half the cost of a replacement.

The national average cost for replacing a gas furnace in the U.S. for a 1,600 to 2,000-square-foot home is about $7,000. However, the cost of furnaces can range widely depending on their size, type, and efficiency, and homeowners can generally expect a new furnace to cost anywhere between $3,800 and $10,000. If efficiency is important to you, high-efficiency models can reach up to $12,000.

When choosing a new furnace, fuel type is one of the most significant factors. It can affect both upfront cost and how much you pay over the life of the furnace. Each type of furnace—whether electric, propane, natural gas, or oil— has its own price range and unique advantages, though gas is the most popular.

Switching to a different type of furnace—say, from electric to natural gas—can be a good investment, especially if you're looking for lower long-term energy costs. But, changing your furnace type often comes with additional expenses beyond just the furnace unit itself.

Here's what you can generally expect to pay for different types of furnaces:

Efficiency is another key factor that can significantly affect both your monthly energy bills and your furnace's environmental impact. Furnace efficiency is measured by the Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rating, which tells you how effectively the furnace turns fuel into heat. The higher the AFUE rating, the more heat you get for every dollar you spend on energy, and the less you waste.

While high-efficiency models generally come with a higher price tag, they can often lead to substantial long-term savings. Here's a breakdown of furnace efficiency levels and their associated costs:

You may be tempted to continue making repairs, which can extend a furnace's life. But an older furnaces that requires extensive repairs may cost more in the long run. Here's a quick comparison:

In addition to the furnace itself, there are often additional expenses associated with a replacement, such as installation and upgrades. However, one way to manage furnace costs more easily is to take advantage of financing options for the furnace itself, allowing you to budget installation separately. Here are some common additional expenses to keep in mind:

• Labor Costs: Professional installation typically ranges from $1,000 to $3,000, depending on the complexity of the job, your location, and the expertise required.
• Ductwork Modifications or Repairs: Aging or damaged ducts can cost $500 – $3,000 to repair or replace.
• Thermostat Replacement: A new thermostat, especially if upgrading to a smart model, costs between $150 and $400.
• Permits and Inspection Fees: Required by some jurisdictions, these fees can add $50 – $300.
• Electrical or Gas Line Modifications: If switching furnace types or upgrading to a more powerful model, modifications to the existing electrical or gas lines may be needed, costing an additional $200 – $700.
• Removal and Disposal of the Old Furnace: Safely removing and disposing of the old furnace can add $50 – $200 to the overall cost.

The size of your furnace also impacts how much you can expect to pay, and choosing the appropriate furnace size for your home is crucial for efficient heating. Simply put, different size furnaces can produce different amounts of heat, and like Goldilocks with her porridge, you're looking for the one that is just right.

To help determine roughly what size furnace you need, you need to know how big your home is. From there, you can use the chart below to calculate your British Thermal Units (which is a measure of heat and energy you may require to heat your home).

While this can give you a pretty good idea of the cost of different sized furnaces, to know precisely which size you need, you may want to work with an expert to factor in things like insulation, glass surfaces, climate, exposed walls or vaulted ceilings.

Understanding furnace replacement costs is the key to making an informed decision to fit your both your heating needs and your budget.

Ready to explore furnace purchase options? Check out today's deals at the Synchrony Marketplace, where our partners come together to offer limited time deals on brands you love.

How long do furnaces last?

Furnaces generally last 15 to 20 years with proper maintenance.

How often should I service my furnace?

It's recommended to service your furnace at least once a year, ideally before the winter season starts.

Are there any rebates or tax credits for upgrading to an energy-efficient furnace?

Yes, many federal and state programs offer tax credits, rebates, or incentives for installing high-efficiency furnaces.

What are the most common furnace issues homeowners face?

Common furnace problems include thermostat malfunctions, dirty or clogged filters, pilot light issues, and blower motor problems.

Can I install a new furnace myself to save on costs?

Furnace installation is complex and should be handled by a licensed professional. Improper installation can lead to safety risks, inefficiency, and may void warranties.